Monday 25 June 2012

Turkish F-4 Phantom jet (file)

Syria shot at second plane, Turkey says


To shoot down one Turkish plane is unfortunate, to shoot at a second Turkish plane is beginning to look like carelessness.
Image result for Evolving tactics of Syrian rebels

Evolving tactics of Syrian rebels


" 'We make the bombs because we lack weapons, because there is no help from outside. Our people are being slaughtered, and no-one else cares.'
What you are witnessing is the rebel army going on the offensive."

Friday 22 June 2012

Bashar al-Assad

Assad may be offered clemency by

At this time of night, I thought it read Assange. But then... if anyone needs the punchline, I'm here all week.

Tuesday 19 June 2012

Image result for joseph holliday syria's armed opposition

syria’s armed opposition

"There's a fellow half in shot on the right, wielding an AK variant and wearing loosely assembled fatigues, but also with a scarf round his neck in Syrian colours which looks very much like his mum knitted it for him. One hopes that both are OK."
From Blood and Treasure's commentary [http://bloodandtreasure.typepad.com/…/not-exactly-hearts-an…] on an assessment of the armed Syrian opposition.

Wednesday 13 June 2012

Image result for leon trotsky

The Young Turks

Leon Trotsky

"In its real significance, a revolution is a fight for control of the State. That rests directly on the Army. This is why all revolutions in history sharply raised the question: on whose side is the army?..The restoration of the Sultan and his despotism would mean the end of Turkey, leaving the Turkish State to the mercy of those who want to carve it up. The victory of Turkish democracy, on the contrary, would mean peace."

Sunday 10 June 2012

The protestant working class

Image result for eamonn mccann

 Eamonn McCann

"The fact that, from the Protestant workers’ point of view, the privilege is pretty small, matters not at all. When tuppence-halfpenny is looking down on tuppence, the halfpenny difference can assume an importance out of all proportion to its actual size."
I think I've read that despite the preponderance of Alawis in the state apparatus, most of those in their traditional homeland in Northwest Syria are poor farmers. So perhaps they are more comparable to the Protestants of Northern Ireland than the Israeli Jews, who as a people-class are all privileged by the dispossession of the Palestinians.

Also:


"The great mass of the people continue, for historical reasons, to see religion, not class, as the basic divide in our society. This sectarian consciousness is reinforced, week in, week out, by local Tory newspapers. The machinations of Catholic and Protestant Tories such as McAteer, Glover, Anderson, and Hegarty are carefully calculated to maintain the status quo. The end result is a working class which is unresponsive to socialist ideas...
One of the basic difficulties arises out of the present division of the working class along religious lines. Many Protestant workers in Derry feel that they are members of a vaguely privileged section of the population (as, in one sense, they are). As a result, despite the economic situation of the area, they are resistant to change. Many of the Catholic workers interpret the bulk of Governmental activity as being to some extent directed against them as Catholics. Thus, they are ‘easy meat’ for the adroit demagogy of the McAteers and Hegartys."
[http://cain.ulst.ac.uk/events/crights/mccann93.htm]

Frederick Engels’ Speech at the Grave of Karl Marx

Marx's gravestone in Highgate cemetry

 "A disproportionate number of Alawis owe their livelihood to the regime. To fight for a post-regime future means to fight for a future in which their community will be, at best, less favoured than at present."

 Most of the debate about Syria is about what people should do, very little is about why they do what they do. At least the above is a start. A hundred and thirty years ago at his friend's funeral, Frederick Engels said he thought his friend had discerned the primary cause:

 "Marx discovered the law of development of human history: the simple fact, hitherto concealed by an overgrowth of ideology, that mankind must first of all eat, drink, have shelter and clothing, before it can pursue politics, science, art, religion, etc.; that therefore the production of the immediate material means, and consequently the degree of economic development attained by a given people or during a given epoch, form the foundation upon which the state institutions, the legal conceptions, art, and even the ideas on religion, of the people concerned have been evolved, and in the light of which they must, therefore, be explained, instead of vice versa, as had hitherto been the case."
 Do the Syrian bourgeoisie and state officials support the regime because they are wrong-headed, or because they benefit from it? Will the lower-level state functionaries be won away from it by being told they'll get a smaller slice of the same cake, or that the cake will be bigger once the parasites stop creaming off the top? If the latter are there irreconcilable interests of those who wish to profit from Syria in the future and those who would have to labour to produce those profits?

 How to overthrow the regime is another question. The working class has the power (in Russia in 1917 it was 2% of the population, I'm sure in Syria it is much higher), but for understandable reasons socialist politics there have been corrupted by Stalinist backers of the status quo. But still the question arises of who else will control any force capable of knocking the regime over; if that is foreign intervention they will impose their own idea of what is good for Syrians, replicating as far as they can the system of exploitation in their own country, whether that is Turkey, Saudi Arabia or the US. And if it is the FSA uncontrolled by the grassroots, then the best that can be hoped for is some sort of military Bonapartism.

 Similar questions arise as to how a post-Assad Syria is to be constructed. Is it simply to be a similar scheme of exploitation, with the Assad family removed and perhaps the facade of a Western-approved democracy, in which those with power and influence compete in elections to show the limited amount they are prepared to share with their own constituencies, while sharing the rest with their corporate friends at home and abroad, à la Iraq?
 These are the sort of questions that should have been asked by John Rees in this dreadful article,http://www.counterfire.org/…/15821-syria-the-left-and-a-rev…. But this supposed dialectician instead sets up a false pro/anti -intervention dialectic, in which the Syrians who don't support intervention supposedly see those who do as a bigger enemy than the regime. To which any anti-regime Syrian will reasonably tell him that he knows nothing and understands less, if they were to be more polite than he deserves.

Saturday 9 June 2012

The German Ideology

Image result for karl marx

 "Syrian rebels tried to get me killed," says Channel 4 correspondent*

 Very stupid if true. On CNN last night they were talking of people fleeing the fighting between the army and rebels (as if they were equal threats), it only takes one incident like this to endorse a picture of a struggle between two equally [il]legitimate forces, just as it would only take one actual sectarian massacre by opposition supporters (say in response to the one in Qubair) for the government and the Russians to say that's all there is to the anti-Assad forces. They do that already, but they'll start to sound believable.

 Here's Marx on how the ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas.
*[
http://www.theguardian.com/media/2012/jun/08/alex-thompson-syrian-rebels]

Friday 8 June 2012

Patrice Lumumba

Anefo 910-9740 De Congolese2.jpg


Dead, living, free, or in prison on the orders of the colonialists, it is not I who counts. It is the Congo, it is our people for whom independence has been transformed into a cage where we are regarded from the outside… History will one day have its say, but it will not be the history that Brussels, Paris, Washington, or the United Nations will teach, but that which they will teach in the countries emancipated from colonialism and its puppets... a history of glory and dignity.”
— Patrice Lumumba, October 1960
For those who might think the UN might help the people of Syria, a reminder of some of the facts of its first intervention. And brilliant though Lumumba was, it was he who made the mistake of thinking the UN would come to help. When Kofi Annan says that the Syrian opposition should stop fighting, it is so the intrigues of the Great Powers can rule the day.

Wednesday 6 June 2012

Image result for tariq ali

‘The notion that democracy and

Just heard Tariq Ali tell Russia Today that it is just the US that doesn't want an orderly transition in Syria, which I think is to noticeably misread the situation there (where the regime isn't going to give up without a fight), but he understands an enormous amount and knows more.
[Also RT had a report on the 150-fold increase in fines for unauthorised protests in Russia, which are still nowhere near the level said to exist in France and the UK,http://rt.com/politics/lower-house-illegal-protests-026/]
http://tariqali.org/archives/2359

Monday 4 June 2012

Scuffle between Syrian air hostesses delays Saudi flight to Dubai



"A scuffle between Syrian air hostesses supporting their country's government and those against it resulted in the delay of a Saudi Arabian Airlines flight to Dubai, a Saudi newspaper reported Monday."

Flight attendants at the front line of revolutionary struggle.

Sunday 3 June 2012


RT had a report on Salafist supporters of Syrian revolution in Lebanon from which the opposite conclusions can be drawn from those that RT do.
Living less in a fantasy world, here's Lord of the Rings on Facebook.

Friday 1 June 2012

Image result for Moscow Mules daily show wyatt cenac jon stewart russia syria

Moscow Mules

Wyatt Cenac reports that Russia's opposition to intervention in Syria is really just an attempt to regain its status as the Evil Empire.